‘Inequality is unsustainable’: a view of the quest for Huntington’s disease treatments from the Global South

(I dedicate this article to the worldwide HD community as we mark Huntington’s Disease Awareness Month in many countries around the planet.)

 

Both the COVID-19 pandemic and the quest for treatments for rare and genetic diseases have laid bare deep social divisions across the world, and it behooves the scientific establishment to help resolve this ethical dilemma, says a leading Brazilian Huntington’s disease clinician.

 

“The world should not be divided between those who have money and those who don’t,” Mônica Santoro Haddad, M.D., a neurologist with 33 years’ practice at the Universidade de São Paulo (USP) School of Medicine, told me in an April 30 Zoom interview about the 16th Annual HD Therapeutics Conference. “The pandemic has already shown us that. This inequality is unsustainable.”

 

Dr. Haddad has assisted HD patients from 600 families at the USP neurology clinic and her private office. A participant in the 2013 Therapeutics Conference in Venice, Italy, and 2014 meeting in Palm Springs, CA, she watched all of this year’s three-day virtual event (April 27-29) online. The conferences are sponsored by CHDI Foundation, Inc.

 

“What we’re witnessing in Brazil [regarding the pandemic] is immoral – Brazil in relationship to the world and Brazil in general,” Dr. Haddad observed, speaking in her native Portuguese. “Two categories of people have been created: those with the vaccine, those without the vaccine.”

 

A South American giant struggles

 

Sadly, Brazil ranks second in the world behind the United States with more than 428,000 COVID-19 deaths.

 

As a history professor, I have dedicated much of my career to the study of Brazil, a country that I consider my second  home; my wife is Brazilian, and her extended family is there. Along the way, I have witnessed the development of the Associação Brasil Huntington and built ties to its leaders.

 

A major country of the Global South – the world’s developing countries – Brazil has an estimated 20,000-plus afflicted individuals and an active HD movement. An enthusiastic group of some 30 Brazilians took part in #HDdennomore, Pope Francis’ special audience with the HD in May 2017. Francis, a native of Argentina, is also the first pontiff from the Global South.

 

However, although Brazil’s medical system has gained international recognition for past vaccine campaigns and its model fight against AIDS, during the pandemic the country has lacked hospital beds, cemetery plots, and basic supplies. Like Donald Trump, Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro denied the crisis, downplayed the dangers, and actively denounced such measures as mask-wearing.

 

In addition, Brazil has fallen victim to the international inequities in the rollout of vaccines. Both U.S. President Joe Biden and former Brazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva – a likely candidate in the 2022 presidential election – have backed waiving COVID-19 vaccine patents to assure global access.

 

Brazil’s deep internal disparities have led to inadequate vaccine distribution to the poor and marginalized.

 

Recognizing similar, longstanding neglect in other South American countries, the humanitarian organization Factor-H has continued to assist abandoned HD families during the crisis.

 

Providing everybody access to medicines

 

Echoing her concerns about COVID-19, Dr. Haddad affirmed the need for a “change in the paradigm” regarding rare and genetic diseases like Huntington’s.

 

As in the U.S. and elsewhere, fear and denial frequently underlie Brazilians’ decisions to avoid genetic testing and facing the terrible medical and social challenges posed by the disease. Many Brazilians have “prejudice against disease” in general, Dr. Haddad told me in a 2013 interview.

 

However, the trend against testing might be shifting for the younger generations, and could also change among older groups when the overall outlook for treatments has improved, Dr. Haddad wrote in a May 14 WhatsApp message. Clinical trials seeking presymptomatic HD gene carriers will require testing, she added.

 

Like medical professionals in many countries, Dr. Haddad believes genetic testing is a personal decision, with the procedure governed by established protocol and with professional medical and psychological support.

 

As of April 2021, the Brazilian government has required all private health plans and insurance to cover genetic testing. This represented a “small advance,” Dr. Haddad asserted in our Zoom interview, because health advocates want to see the country’s free public health service also provide that benefit.

 

For Dr. Haddad, for HD to be defeated, inequality must diminish.

 

“The question is: is it ethical to diagnose someone with one of those diseases and not have a treatment available?” Dr. Haddad said. “This is a question that I discuss with my patients and with my colleagues.”

 

She added: “It is certainly not ethical to have a treatment that not everybody has access to.”

 

The HD Therapeutics Conference left her with her “hope battery recharged” and confident that a treatment is possible, Dr. Haddad said.

 

 

Gene Veritas interviewing Dr. Mônica Haddad (screenshot by Gene Veritas, aka Kenneth P. Serbin)

 

Advocating for open science

 

At the close of the conference, Dr. Haddad was inspired by the presentation by featured speaker Aled Edwards, Ph.D., who in 2004 founded the Structural Genomix Consortium (SGC), which practices and advocates for open sharing of scientific information, particularly as it applies to protein science, chemical biology, and drug discovery.

 

Dr. Edwards, the SGC CEO and a scientist based at the University of Toronto, spoke on “HD drug discovery in the public domain – a model for CHDI.” A breath of “fresh air,” Dr. Edwards’ talk pointed the way to reducing inequality, Dr. Haddad told me.

 

“What we would also like to do is develop a drug discovery ecosystem that prioritizes affordability and global access, and, of course, to do this in collaboration with industry,” Dr. Edwards stated. “Now this might sound naïve, but I’d like to emphasize there’s quite a bit of drug discovery experience in the SGC and in our network.”

 

Dr. Edwards presented examples of researchers who have followed the open science model – including 16 “HD open science programs” that share science “as they go,” with some even blogging about their findings. He highlighted the work of Rachel Harding, Ph.D., an SGC researcher and postdoctoral fellow at the University of Toronto who achieved the “very challenging” task of purifying the huntingtin protein to a “resolution that is practically useful” to other scientists.

 

Dr. Harding has widely shared both the protein and reagents (compounds that facilitate chemical reactions) that enable the making of the protein, ultimately aiming to inform the discovery of potential HD drugs, in particular so-called small-molecule drugs, Dr. Edwards explained.

 

Discussed at the Therapeutics Conference, these drugs become distributed very evenly across the whole body, including the brain, whereas several drugs in other current or recently completed clinical trials need to be injected directly into the brain or via spinal tap.

 

“This is a really fantastic contribution to the public good that these folks have made,” Dr. Edwards said of Dr. Harding’s team.

 

Sharing science as they go: Huntington's disease "open science champs" as presented by Dr. Aled Edwards, at upper right (screenshot by Gene Veritas)

 

Seeking more efficient drug discovery

 

Dr. Edwards underscored a key point: despite spending $300 billion globally each year on research and development and producing many hugely successful drugs, the biomedical field is highly inefficient. “We need to do better as a society,” he asserted.

 

“For many diseases – Huntington’s, Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s – we don’t even know the molecular mechanism of the disease, let alone how to design a therapeutic strategy,” Dr. Edwards said, adding that a system in which the “first past the post gets the money” in designing drugs has required “the pricing of medicines at levels that are unaffordable for most people on the planet.”

 

Dr. Edwards displayed data demonstrating how globally most research focuses on the familiar rather than explore new, potentially crucial areas of biology. Similarly, in industry, companies pursue drugs in parallel rather than collaborate, wasting valuable resources, he added.

 

SGC is working against the grain, trying to create the way for a new scientific culture. The SGC never files for patents “as a core principle,” Dr. Edwards explained. “All of the work we do goes into the public domain, including the reagents that we make.”

 

If labs and companies openly shared data before doing the final crucial test on a potential drug in a Phase 3 trial, the field could not only save money, but test multiple drugs at the same time, he said.

 

Rather than rely on patents, the system should take advantage of federal laws that give companies protection from competition for a fixed period, generally five to twelve years, Dr. Edwards affirmed. The law provides even longer periods for orphan and pediatric drugs.

 

Supporting the public good

 

“There is no law of physics that says industry has to invent a drug,” Dr. Edwards said. “That’s the social system that we’ve put in place. Let’s imagine a different system.”

 

To “walk the walk about open drug discovery,” SGC established the Agora Open Science Trust, a registered charity in Canada modeled on Newman’s Own Foundation, which funnels profits from food products with the picture of the late Academy-Award-Winning actor into philanthropy.

 

Dr. Edwards described its goal: “To support open science and the public good, and price new medicines to ensure global access. Whether you’re a rich American or live in Thailand, you’re going to get the medicine at a price you can afford.”

 

In its first project, Agora has focused on children’s cancers. As of yet the trust has not announced a plan for an HD drug program, although Dr. Edwards and the above-mentioned HD open science researchers have an abiding interest in finding treatments.

 

Indeed, regarding those treatments, Dr. Edwards concluded that “if we do it as a collective, we’ll get further faster.”

 

 

Dr. Aled Edwards explains the creation of for-profit drug companies to fund the Agora Open Science Trust, whose mission is to ensure global, affordable access to new medicines (screenshot by Gene Veritas).

 

Knowledge belongs to the world

 

If Dr. Edwards and SGC achieve their goals, they will have a place in history, Dr. Haddad observed. The emphasis on sharing data will “democratize” knowledge, she added.

 

“It’s obvious that a company does things to earn money,” Dr. Haddad continued. She noted, however, that Dr. Edwards is asking scientists and others to put their vanity aside to help the suffering.

 

Brazil has not yet hosted, and may not host in the future, any sites for the major HD clinical trials, Dr. Haddad pointed out. She noted that the local HD community attempted to bring to Brazil the historic Phase 3 gene silencing clinical trial by Roche, which reported the unfavorable results at the HD Therapeutics Conference. In South America, Roche ran the trial in Argentina and Chile.

 

“We did the paperwork to try to include a Brazilian research center, and because of questions raised by an ethics committee and political and legal issues, we were unsuccessful,” Dr. Haddad explained. “Brazil did not permit genetic material [from the clinical trial] to be sent out of the country.”

 

For now, Dr. Haddad said, Brazilians can at least look forward to the possibility of their government’s authorization of the drug Austedo, approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in 2017 for chorea, the involuntary movements that occur in many HD-affected individuals.

 

At this time, Brazil’s lack of participation in clinical trials of drugs that aim to slow or stop the disease is “not important,” Dr. Haddad concluded. Echoing Dr. Edwards – and the hope of thousands of Brazilian HD families anxiously awaiting the arrival of effective treatments but fearful that the country might not be able to afford them – she added: “The knowledge obtained belongs to the world.”

After a horrid year, free streaming of ‘Dancing at the Vatican’ is an inspirational gift and a call to aid Huntington’s disease families

Dancing at the Vatican, the 38-minute documentary featuring South American Huntington’s disease-afflicted families’ remarkable 2017 encounter with Pope Francis at the Vatican, will be streamed indefinitely on YouTube for free starting December 1.

“The film has a distinct Christmas theme – the surprise invitations to the HD families in Latin America all arrived on the Epiphany,” wrote Dancing at the Vatican producer and narrator Charles Sabine in a recent e-mail to me, referring to the Catholic feast day, January 6, on which the HD families in South America received the official invitations to meet the pope. “So, I am going to be encouraging people to regard this as an inspirational gift at the end of a pretty horrid year.”

 

HD families from Colombia, Venezuela, and the pope’s homeland, Argentina, had met with the pontiff at #HDdennomore: Pope Francis’ Special Audience with the Huntington’s Disease Community in Solidarity with South America (click here to read more). Some 1,500 HD family members and their supporters – including my family and me – attended from around the world.

 

For the first time, a world leader had recognized Huntington’s disease.

 

Pope Francis with HD families in Rome, May 18, 2017 (photo by #HDdennomore)

 

Online starting December 1

 

Starting December 1, you can watch Dancing at the Vatican by clicking here. Also, the English-language film now has versions with subtitles in French, German, Italian, Portuguese, and Spanish.

 

The producers request that people click on the “subscribe” button on YouTube and leave comments on the film to help facilitate tracking of its viewings and to further support the HD cause. In the spirit of a heartwarming holiday gift, they also ask that viewers share the video with at least two people who have not heard about HD before.

 

According to Ignacio Muñoz-Sanjuán, Ph.D., a leading HD researcher and a co-organizer of #HDdennomore along with Sabine, the papal audience brought “critical” recognition to HD families living in “extremely vulnerable conditions.”

 

“This has touched them and their communities in many ways,” Dr. Muñoz wrote me. “But their plight continues, and the documentary should be a call to action to help those in most need, regardless of where they live in the world.”

 

In the spirit of Dancing at the Vatican, the HD community can come together to “give voice to the voiceless” and raise badly needed funds for local patient associations as well as Factor-H, a nonprofit organization that he co-founded to aid Latin American HD families, Dr. Muñoz added.

 

A message for all faiths and backgrounds

 

Dancing at the Vatican captures key moments of the impoverished, disease-stricken families’ extraordinary journey – some had never ventured beyond their home towns; some even lacked birth certificates – to their meeting with the Spanish-speaking Francis, the first Latin American pontiff in the Catholic Church’s 2000-year history.

 

#HDdennomore was open to people of all faiths and backgrounds, as were the three in-person screenings of Dancing at the Vatican in Los Angeles, London, and San Diego.

 

Sabine and the film’s organizers had hoped to organize additional screenings in the U.S., Europe, and South America.

 

However, the COVID-19 pandemic – which has made 2020 a trying year for all of humanity – forced the organizers to scuttle those plans. Instead, they have focused on the plan to provide free online access to Dancing at the Vatican.

 

Depending on the local impact of the pandemic, some communities might organize in-person screenings, Sabine explained.

 

“For example, in New Zealand, where COVID-19 has been virtually eradicated, there will be screenings in the first week of December in actual full movie theatres,” he noted.

 

Taking on HD families’ suffering

 

Sabine said that the Vatican’s communications department will help promote the online launch. In addition, the producers will promote the film “on all the relevant family organization websites and social media” and also reach out to clinicians, pharmaceutical companies, and nonprofits involved in HD, he said.

 

The screenings and publicity about the online screenings have been sponsored by Roche, Ionis Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Wave Live Sciences, and Takeda.

 

According to Sabine, the film demonstrates that “anything can be achieved if you put together enough people who believe that nothing is impossible.”

 

Also, he suggested, the HD community can use Dancing at the Vatican to promote the cause by “showing that, as Pope Francis said, it is time for HD families to be ‘Hidden No More.’” 

 

Dr. Muñoz pointed out that HD continues to devastate the South American families portrayed in the film. (An upcoming article will update the families’ stories.)

 

The film and the efforts of advocates such as Sabine and Dr. Muñoz echo the words of Pope Francis, who in his speech at #HDdennomore emphasized “what Jesus himself taught us.”

 

“Throughout his ministry, he met many sick people,” Francis stated. “He took on their suffering; he tore down the walls of stigma and of marginalization that prevented so many of them from feeling respected and loved.”

Planning a ‘Dancing at the Vatican’ screening to celebrate the global Huntington’s disease community’s journey

On February 19, the University of San Diego (USD) will host the world’s third screening of Dancing at the Vatican, the short documentary featuring South American Huntington’s disease-afflicted families’ historic 2017 encounter with Pope Francis at the Vatican.

As I noted in my preview before the July 2019 premiere of this 38-minute film in Los Angeles, Dancing at the Vatican captures key moments of those impoverished, disease-stricken families’ journey to their meeting with the Spanish-speaking Francis, the first Latin American pontiff in the Catholic Church’s 2000-year history. It was extraordinary: some had never ventured beyond their home towns; some even lacked birth certificates.

Now, as both an HD advocate and faculty member in USD’s Department of History, I’m helping organize the upcoming screening, and hope many more people will see it. 

Dancing at the Vatican also will be shown in London on February 5. Showings are also confirmed for Washington, D.C., in March (date and place TBA), and at the Huntington’s Disease Youth Organization conference in Glasgow, Scotland, in May. Screenings are under consideration for South America, too. Ultimately, the film will become available online.

In the words of producer and narrator Charles Sabine – like me, a presymptomatic HD gene carrier – coming together to view Dancing at the Vatican is an occasion of “extraordinary celebration” for the Huntington’s community.

An Emmy-award-winning former NBC-TV foreign correspondent, Sabine helped spearhead “HDdennomore: Pope Francis’ Special Audience with the Huntington’s Disease Community in Solidarity with South America.” Both Sabine's father and brother died from HD.

While Dancing at the Vatican captures what I called in my preview “the underside of the HD world” – families dealing simultaneously with one of humanity’s most devastating diseases and severe poverty and discrimination – it also portrays what Sabine described as “happy tales set against the dark canvas of our disease.”

At HDdennomore, and as the film recalls, Francis became the first world leader to recognize this horrible disease. And he declared that it should be “hidden no more.” 

Pope Francis with HD families in Rome, May 18, 2017 (photo by #HDdennomore)

Faith, reason, and advocacy

At USD, the primary sponsor of the screening is Frances G. Harpst Center for Catholic Thought and Culture (CCTC). Along with other USD units, the CCTC co-sponsored my trip to Rome for #HDdennomore, and also my public presentation on the event (click here to watch).

USD is a Catholic university where “faith and reason are compatible in education,” and it “welcomes students, faculty and staff of every faith tradition,” according to its statement on Catholic identity. Indeed, since my arrival in 1993, I’ve faced no restrictions on my research on abortion in Brazil, and have taught students from many religious backgrounds.

I have explored the nexus between faith and reason/science in this blog, including the in-depth article “God, Huntington’s disease and the meaning of life.”

After CCTC Director Jeffrey Burns, Ph.D., read my preview of Dancing at the Vatican last July, he e-mailed me to ask whether we could bring the film to USD. Sabine readily agreed to the idea; he’ll introduce the film and take questions afterwards.

Ignacio Muñoz-Sanjuán, Ph.D., a leading neuroscientist seeking HD treatments at the Los Angeles office of the nonprofit CHDI Foundation, Inc., also will speak. Dr. Muñoz helped organize #HDdennomore. He co-founded Factor-H, which aids Latin America’s poor HD-affected families. Both Sabine and Muñoz will also meet with students and faculty interested in their respective professional fields.

We selected the February 19 date because Sabine, based in London, will join Muñoz and several hundred researchers from around the globe the next week at the CHDI-sponsored 15th Annual HD Therapeutics Conference in nearby Palm Springs, CA. I will also attend.

In planning the screening, I’ve strengthened the bond between advocacy and academic work that USD values and that I began to establish after exiting the terrible and lonely “HD closet” in 2012 (click here to read more).

Dr. Ignacio Muñoz-Sanjuán entering the Vatican with Dilia Oviedo Guillén, a Colombian woman who lost her husband and five children to HD (photo by #HDdennomore)

A free event, with many sponsors

The screening will take place from 6:30-8:30 p.m. in USD’s Manchester Auditorium (located in Manchester Hall) and will be followed by a reception. The event is free and open to the USD community, the local HD and biomedical communities, and the public. Attendees must register at cctc@sandiego.edu or 619-260-7936.

To fund the event, we have secured support from Ionis Pharmaceuticals, Inc., the developer of the gene-silencing drug currently under study in a historic Phase 3 clinical trial by Roche. (Click here for a recent update on the trial.) Ionis is located in Carlsbad, CA, part of the San Diego-area biotech hub, one of the world’s most important. Ionis’ chief scientific officer and HD team leader, Frank Bennett, Ph.D., donated to #HDdennomore.

In addition, Roche’s U.S. subsidiary Genentech will also sponsor the screening. Headquartered in South San Francisco, CA, Genentech also has a facility in Oceanside, just north of San Diego. 

Another local company, Origami Therapeutics, Inc., is supporting the event. It also seeks to develop an HD treatment. It was founded by Beth Hoffman, Ph.D., the former president of the San Diego chapter of the Huntington’s Disease Society of America.

Other USD co-sponsors include the International Center, the Enhanced Student Faculty Interaction Fund, the Humanities Center, the above-mentioned Department of History, the Program in Latin American Studies, and the Department of Communication Studies. The College of Arts and Sciences also has lent its support.

Charles Sabine dancing at the Vatican with #HDdennomore participants (photo by #HDdennomore)

‘All of us standing together’

On January 10, I had a long lunch with George Essig, a well-connected veteran radio ad salesman and former HDSA-San Diego president. Essig’s extended family is affected by HD. As I wrote in a 2014 article, Essig “epitomizes the dedication of the unaffected relative.” (Click here to read more.)

In discussing the screening, we noted that it will be a unique event for the San Diego HD community and its supporters. Over the years, most events – such as galas, marathons, and walks – have focused on raising funds and awareness.

Echoing Sabine, I stressed that this event would be a celebration.

We brainstormed on the meaning of “celebration” for the local HD community – and for the many donors Essig has brought into the cause.

Their support had helped HD “become hidden no more,” he said. 

The screening also will be about “the evolution of the cause,” he added. 

With that in mind, Essig said he would tell supporters that he would be “remiss not to invite you to this celebration.”

The Dancing at the Vatican screening will also celebrate the progress in research, which has advanced thanks to the donors and broad collaboration in the HD community, he noted.

Essig summed it up: the Dancing at the Vatican event will be “all of us standing together and saying: I helped bring a cure to an incurable disease, even if it’s just $10 that I gave.”

(Disclosure: I hold a symbolic amount of Ionis shares.)

‘Dancing at the Vatican,’ about Huntington’s families’ remarkable papal audience, premieres July 27

Dancing at the Vatican, a short documentary featuring South American Huntington’s disease-afflicted families’ remarkable 2017 encounter with Pope Francis at the Vatican, will premiere in Los Angeles on July 27.

The 38-minute film captures key moments of those impoverished, disease-stricken families’ extraordinary journey – some had never ventured beyond their home towns; some even lacked birth certificates – to their meeting with the Spanish-speaking Francis, the first Latin American pontiff in the Catholic Church’s 2000-year history.

The documentary is narrated by Emmy-award-winning former NBC-TV foreign correspondent Charles Sabine – like me, an asymptomatic HD gene carrier – and one of the lead organizers of “HDdennomore: Pope Francis’ Special Audience with the Huntington’s Disease Community in Solidarity with South America.”

“In the course of 26 years as a television journalist, living through more than a dozen wars, five revolutions, and four earthquakes, I witnessed many examples of people achieving the seemingly impossible,” Sabine says in introducing the film, which I previewed online July 21. “None, though, was as inspirational as the tale I’m about to tell.”

The film portrays the struggles of HD family members such as Dilia Oviedo Guillén, a Colombian woman who lost her husband and five children to the disease.

Dilia provides 24-hour care to four more adult children. “I have to wash, cook, and feed them,” she says in the film. “You have to do all that for them. They can’t use their hands to eat. They’re my children, so I feel as if I have their illness.”

Dilia has no professional caregivers or physical therapists to assist her. The family is so poor that she had to bury three of her children in a single grave.

In showing the struggles of Dilia’s family and others, Dancing at the Vatican captures the underside of the HD world. Such families deal with one of the humanity’s most devastating diseases and severe poverty, lack of opportunities, poor or non-existent infrastructure, neglect by the government and society, and stigma and discrimination.

However, as Sabine wrote me in an e-mail today, he and the filmmakers also sought to include "happy tales set against the dark canvass of our disease."

“‘Pope meets sick people’ was not a headline the world’s media would care about,” Sabine wrote.  “‘Pope meets sick people with an extraordinary visual backstory,’ was.”

The film follows Dilia’s family and four others as they tour Rome; are received in the Italian Senate by its president and world-renowned HD researcher, Senator for Life, and #HDdennomore organizer Elena Cattaneo; and anticipate the big moment with Pope Francis.

From the Dancing at the Vatican website. Dilia Oviedo Guillén is pictured in the center.

Proceeds benefit Factor-H

The premiere will take place at the SilverScreen Theater, Pacific Design Center, 8687 Melrose Avenue, West Hollywood, CA. Doors open at 5:30 p.m., with a screening of the film at 6 p.m., followed by a Q&A and refreshments. Actress and singer Kate Miner, also from an HD family and a participant in the papal audience, will emcee the evening. Self-parking on the street or at the Center ($10) is available.

Directed at the HD community and the general public, the event and the film seek to raise awareness about HD and, as key HD researcher Ignacio Muñoz-Sanjuan, Ph.D., wrote in an e-mail, “the desperate situation of many HD families in Latin America.”

Sponsored by HD-focused drug developers Ionis Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Genentech, and Wave Life Sciences, admission to the premiere is free. (Click here to register.)

Sabine recorded a one-minute video personally inviting the HD community to participate in this “extraordinary celebration.”

Those who wish can contribute to Factor-H, a nonprofit that seeks to improve the quality of life of poor HD families in Latin America. Founded by Spanish-born neuroscientist Dr. Muñoz-Sanjuan and the Argentine physician Claudia Perandones, both featured in Dancing at the Vatican, Factor-H currently supports families in Chile, Colombia, Peru, and Venezuela. Venezuela’s Lake Maracaibo region has one of the world’s densest clusters of HD families, with many residents donating blood in the scientific quest for the HD gene.

Instrumental in #HDdennomore, Drs. Muñoz-Sanjuan and Perandones saw the papal audience as a way to further Factor-H’s work. The organization seeks to expand assistance to other nations.

Sabine and the filmmakers chose Los Angeles for the world premiere because Southern California is a “‘perfect storm’of the HD community – a collaboration of the best of researchers, advocates, clinicians and support groups,” Sabine wrote. However, he also recalled the “truly international nature of the event and film,” noting that 28 countries were represented at #HDdennomore.

In fact, the film has planned premieres in Washington, D.C., London, Rome, Glasgow (Scotland), and South America. Later it will become available online.

Bringing joy and hope

My wife Regina, daughter Bianca, and Brazilian mother-in-law Lourdes took part in #HDdennomore (click here to read more). 

We watched Pope Francis declare that HD should be “hidden no more.”

“It is not simply a slogan, so much as a commitment that we all must foster,” the pope urged the audience of some 1,500 HD community members from around the world.

The film depicts how, after his speech, Francis greeted and hugged each member of the HD-afflicted South American families, sometimes caressing their heads as they spoke to him and cried.

Watching Dancing at the Vatican took me back to those poignant moments in the papal meeting hall. I teared up, as I did that day. 

As Sabine states in the film, #HDdennomore was “the biggest event in the history of Huntington’s disease.”

Dancing at the Vatican underscores the deep medical and social suffering of HD, which, in South America, is exacerbated by poverty and inequality.

However, as the film also shows, those HD families got a wonderful moment to celebrate, smile, and dance.

Thanks to the organizers of #HDdennomore, Factor-H, and Pope Francis, the terrible burden of HD perhaps feels a bit lighter for all affected families. We can all share in that joy – and the hope offered by Francis – by watching Dancing at the Vatican.

(For background on #HDdennomore and its impact, click here and here. A future article will explore Factor-H in depth.)

Francis made a day of ‘superlatives’ for the Huntington’s disease community, says event co-organizer

Pope Francis created a moment of “superlatives” for the Huntington’s disease community in his historic May 18 meeting with HD-afflicted families, international advocate Charles Sabine said a day later, citing record involvement in the cause, global awareness, and a “poignant” focus on HD’s tough challenges.

A former foreign correspondent for NBC News and presymptomatic carrier of the HD gene, Sabine helped organize “HDdennomore, Pope Francis’s Special Audience with the Huntington’s Disease Community in Solidarity with South America” (click here for background on the event).

Sabine, as did prominent HD scientist and Italian senator-for-life Elena Cattaneo, read an introductory statement preceding Francis’s own speech.

“Your Holiness, today marks a new chapter in the history of humanity’s forgotten families,” Sabine told the pontiff as the audience and web viewers from around the planet listened. “Never before has a world leader recognized the suffering of Huntington’s patients and their carers.”

He described HD as the “harshest affliction known to mankind” and also the “most misunderstood, and until today, the most hidden.” Despite that, Huntington’s has never defeated the human spirit, Sabine asserted. Francis could now affirm that “it is not a sin” to have HD.

Thanking the pope on behalf of the HD community, Sabine praised Francis’s “wisdom” and “compassion, which has shone the light of your church on our disease, at last, so that it be hidden no more.”

In his own stirring speech, Francis elaborated on some of Sabine’s points and declared that HD disease should indeed be “hidden no more!”

Visiting the HD families

The day after, Sabine visited the several dozen HD family members from South America, a main focus of HDdennomore, at their lodgings, the Passionist fathers’ monastery. Located in the historic center of Rome just south of the Colosseum and with a large inner courtyard, the monastery provided the HD families with an idyllic setting for repose and meals. HDdennomore provided transportation to the Vatican and other sites during the week-long stay in Rome.

Charles Sabine (center, white shirt), flanked by HDdennomore co-organizers Ignacio Muñoz-Sanjuan, Ph.D., and Senator Elena Cattaneo, Ph.D., and surrounded by South American HD family members (photo by Gene Veritas, aka Kenneth P. Serbin)

The guests included the juvenile-HD-afflicted 15-year-old Brenda of Buenos Aires, Argentina, the pope’s hometown, and 13-year-old Anyervi, a member of an HD family from Venezuela’s Lake Maracaibo region, the site for decades of critical research in the search for the HD gene led by Nancy Wexler, Ph.D., who attended the event. Both Anyervi and Brenda have been ostracized by other children because of prejudice regarding HD.

Before the pope’s arrival for the audience, Sabine called the two on stage individually. Anyervi received a soccer ball and jersey signed by Brazilian soccer superstar Neymar, who greeted the boy in a short video. Brenda was serenaded in person by Argentine smash-hit singer-songwriter Axel.

Sabine’s reflections

At the monastery, an upbeat Sabine circulated among the families and HD advocates, conversing and joking. He took a break to speak with me about his impressions of the event in its immediate aftermath.

GV: What is your feeling about the meeting with the pope?

CS: It’s mostly a feeling of immense relief that, after a year and a half of planning, on a day when a more than a million things could have gone wrong, nothing major did. That’s my immediate sense.

But I’m so extraordinarily pleased at the words of Pope Francis. That was beyond my control other than the set of notes which I gave him in preparation, which he requested, about the disease. He could not have been more eloquent, poignant, and to the point and focused on the real problems and issues that you and I and everyone else faces with this disease.

And he eloquently and, I believe, truthfully and sincerely made the point that this disease should be – and he used these words – “hidden no more.” And that is something that I could never really have dreamt would happen in my lifetime.

GV: That he’d actually use those words?

CS: Yes. But he did say – and this is important – that it is a great slogan but that it must become more than just a slogan. That’s now what we’ve got to do.

GV: So that’s the question, Charles: what comes next for “HDdennmore” and this whole movement?

CS: Well, I was a little surprised when I read in The Washington Post this morning that the “HDdennomore” event in the Vatican yesterday was the beginning of an initiative. That sounds a little bit daunting. It was the initiative to me! To hear it described as a beginning is both daunting and exciting. Okay, I’ll take that. Let’s call this just the beginning. Where next? Washington? London? We’ll see.

GV: So you’re kind of basking in the joy of this for the time being?

CS: Yeah, I’m just so pleased for all of these families who are standing here in this courtyard of this peaceful Passionisti convent here in Rome with all of these patients. I saw many of these patients a month ago in their homes in Maracaibo. Physically they appear better. They are absolutely flying. They are all smiling, they’re all laughing, they’re all talking.

Okay, they have just had a pretty amazing experience, but it just shows really what can happen. Already we’ve had messages from all over the world of people not only just congratulating us. I’m stunned how many people watched the event. I had no idea that so many people would watch it. I’ve had messages from people who were watching it in the middle of the night on the West Coast. There was one nurse whose family were watching it in the Philippines. People were watching this all over the world.

South American HD families preparing for a group photo at the Passionist fathers' monastery, May 19, 2017 (photo by Gene Veritas)

The reaction has already been intense. We’ve had messages of just not support for the event, but also financial bequests. Anyervi, the little 13-year-old who got the Neymar shirt, he’s already had a wealthy benefactor in Italy who’s asked to sponsor him now for the rest of his life. We’ve had other requests to help.

We had a meeting just yesterday, which followed after our event, with industrialists who are looking into ways in which they can help South American families, in particular in Venezuela, where one of them has land he’s donating now with a view to providing food. There was a clinicians’ meeting after that. They were coming up with ideas for working together to get drugs and medical services into South America. It’s already happening.

Anyervi of Venezuela (photo by Gene Veritas)

GV: Did you have a meeting with a cardinal and/or other people in the Vatican afterwards?

CS: Yes, I wasn’t present at them, but there have also been meetings with cardinals to get across the points that Pope Francis made so eloquently and directly about how this disease has been ignored.

And he admitted it. He was very frank. The pope said and was implicitly admitting that his church had failed. He didn’t want to say it like that, but he said these people have been ignored. He didn’t say these people have been ignored, but not by the Church. He said they’ve been ignored. That means they’ve been ignored by the Church. And that’s a wonderful admission.

What we need to do now is to insure that his words are now made into actions on the ground by the cardinals, the archbishops, and the priests across not just South America but all around the world to make it understood that this should be a disease that no one should feel, as I said in my words there, that it is a sin. I spoke to the pope yesterday. I said thank you for making clear the truth – one of the truths that’s been omitted from this disease for centuries – which is that it’s not a sin to have Huntington’s disease in your family.

GV: The pope mentioned the issue of embryonic stem cells. Do you want to comment on that?

CS: It was a little bit of a shame that he did that. It’s the one thing about that speech that was a little bit disappointing. I don’t think he needed to get into that because it wasn’t particularly relevant to that event.

Unfortunately, many of the newspapers from around the world have taken that as a headline, which is a bit of a shame. [The Pope stated that no scientific research, no matter how “noble” its goal, “can justify the destruction of human embryos.”] Of course, that’s an issue that’s still a stumbling block with the Catholic Church. But I personally don’t think that for one second his mentioning that in his talk should take one iota away from the fact that it was a resounding, total success.

Pope Francis during the HDdennomore special audience (photo by Gene Veritas)

GV: Do we know who wrote the pope’s speech?

CS: I don’t know. I gave him three pages of notes that talked about what we go through, including, in particular, the shame and the stigma. And certainly the themes that were in that I saw in there. I don’t whether he wrote it or if he had others. But they wrote it very, very well.

It was really, I thought, brilliantly working in, as he would naturally, the point of mercy and Jesus. The event yesterday personified yesterday more than any other event exactly that new philosophy of his of putting mercy before doctrine, which is not a popular one amongst many on the right.

But the fact is, there were so many superlatives yesterday. There were 1,700 people there, according to the Associated Press and Reuters. That was by far and away the largest collection of people with regard to Huntington’s disease, by some measure. There were 150 patients – at least – that were there, and probably a lot more. That in itself is another record. There have never been that many people in one room affected by Huntington’s disease. There could have been people in there affected by disease that we didn’t meet.

There were at least 27 countries represented. I don’t know whether that’s a record, but certainly the other two are.

(My trip to Rome was made possible by the College of Arts and Sciences, the Frances G. Harpst Center for Catholic Thought and Culture, the International Center, and the Department of History of the University of San Diego. I am grateful for the institutional and moral support of my colleagues and students.)